Lot 12813: 2023 Audi S4 Prestige

On the used market? Absolutely yes—here’s why the Prestige makes sense on this particular car.

The reality of S4 pricing:

I found 9 comparable 2023 S4s on Classic.com, and interestingly, Prestige models are actually averaging less than Premium Plus—about $42K vs $45K. Why? Prestige examples often have slightly higher mileage, but at this price point you’re not paying a premium for the trim.

This specific car at $44,880 with 39k miles:

You’re getting the full Prestige treatment—head-up display, ventilated and heated front and rear seats, Bang & Olufsen audio, matrix LED headlights, traffic sign recognition, and top-view cameras. That’s roughly $4K–6K in extras if you were to add them individually, but more importantly, this one has both the S Sport Package (sport diff, adaptive suspension, dynamic steering) and Black Optic Plus (blacked trim, unique wheels). Those are the options that actually transform how the S4 drives and looks.

The bottom line:

You’ll find Premium Plus S4s asking $46K–$48K with similar or lower miles. This Prestige undercuts those while offering more tech and the desirable performance packages. For an everyday sport sedan that’ll do daily commutes and backroad runs equally well, this is the spec to buy.

Want to see how it compares to other current listings? Check out the B9 S4 market here: https://classic.com/m/audi/a4/b9/s4/

Is there anything specific about the S Sport Package or Black Optic features you’d like me to explain?