Lot STKM18246: 2023 BMW M440i xDrive

Short answer: Yes, the M440i is absolutely worth it over the M4 for most buyers.

Here’s the breakdown from our Classic.com market data:

The Money

• M440i xDrive: ~$47K average used price
• M4: ~$63K average (base) or ~$82K (Competition)
• You’re saving $15,000–$35,000 going with the M440i

The Performance

• M440i: 382 hp, 0-60 in ~4.6 seconds
• M4: 473 hp (base) or 503 hp (Comp), 0-60 in ~4.1 or ~3.5 seconds
• Real-world gap? The M440i is plenty quick — the M4 only pulls ahead when you’re really pushing it

The Practical Stuff

• M440i wins: Standard AWD (xDrive), better fuel economy, cheaper insurance, lower maintenance costs (B58 engine is famously reliable)
• M4 wins: Better resale value (holds ~84% vs 76% for M440i), available manual transmission, track-focused suspension

Who should get what?

• M440i = Daily driver who wants fast, comfortable, and reasonably affordable
• M4 = Track junkie or someone who must have the ultimate version

The M440i delivers about 80% of the M4’s performance at 65% of the price — that’s a solid value play in my book.

Check out similar M440i xDrive models or M4s on our market pages if you want to compare what’s available right now.

Can I help you find any specific M440i or M4 listings, or answer anything else?