home chevron_right

1958 Pontiac Star Chief

VIN: P858H25415
visibility 76
View count is the number of times the vehicle detail page has been opened in the past thirty days.
For Sale
$57,000
Sep 18, 2025
Private Seller
South Windsor, Connecticut, USA
30,807 mi TMU
Automatic
LHD
Original & Highly Original
  • OVERVIEW
  • DESCRIPTION
  • MEDIA
  • HISTORY (3)
  • SPECS
  • COMPS (16)
  • TAXONOMY
  • outlined_flag Report this Listing

About this 1958 Pontiac Star Chief

VIN: P858H25415

THE PONTIAC STAR CHIEF
This classic two-door hardtop coupe is a rolling piece of art on four wheels, repainted correct Redwood Copper with Patina Ivory, chrome-accented side spear, and Redwood hardtop. The car has exquisite chrome bumpers and an original grill in great condition. The two-tone interior is in exceptional condition with newer seat star patterned upholstery and a restored chrome dash showing 37807 miles, which is not the actual mileage as the car was completely restored with a rebuilt engine and transmission and not driven more than 500 miles since. With a stylish dash and crystal clear gauges, this particular Star Chief retains the original Pontiac radio, rebuilt by Mike Hagen and crack-free steering wheel. A factory-correct 389 cubic inch V8 engine sits under the hood and is nicely optioned with power steering and power brakes. Vintage Air Conditioning was also added. The undercarriage is solid and has new dual exhaust, mufflers and tail pipes. This American classic is rolling on original Pontiac steel wheels, Pontiac wheel cover, and wide white wall tires.
FEATURES
• -Complete Frame-off Restoration, every nut & bolt
• -All Chrome parts were re-chromed and the stainless was polished
• -Repainted in Redwood Copper and Patina Ivory
• -New special fitted carpet
• -New original Pontiac steering wheel
• -Factory original Pontiac AM radio w/dual rear speakers, rebuilt for FM.
• -Electric antenna
• -Solid, original, intact and redone UNDERCARRIAGE
• -Vintage Air A/C added with the look of original style

HISTORY OF THE PONTIAC STAR CHIEF
The 1958 Pontiac Star Chief was part of the second-generation Star Chief lineup produced by Pontiac from 1954 to 1958. The '58 Star Chief received a significant styling update compared to previous model years. It featured a more extravagant and flamboyant design with prominent chrome accents, quad headlamps, and a wider grille. The tail fins were prominent and swept-back, reflecting the design trends of the era. The standard engine was a 370 cubic inch (6.1-liter) V8, which produced approximately 230 horsepower. Optional engines included a 389 cubic inch (6.4-liter) V8 with various carburetor configurations, such as a 2-barrel or Tri-Power setup, offering higher horsepower ratings. The 1958 Pontiac Star Chief represents an era of bold styling and increased focus on luxury within the American automotive industry.

Have a question? Ask Rusty
info
These answers are AI generated and may sometimes display incorrect information. They do not represent Classic.com's values or opinions. By using this chatbot you agree to our Terms and Conditions.

Rusty Logo beta

Get instant answers with AI powered search of listing information.

Powered by CLASSIC.com

Market Summary

The Pontiac Star Chief - 3rd Gen (1958 to 1958) market. See Similar Markets

Loading...
The third generation Pontiac Star Chief was introduced for the 1958 model year. Offered only for 1958, the thrid generation Star Chief was f... Learn more.
There is 13 Pontiac Star Chief for sale across all model years (1954 to 1966) and variants, 1 is 3rd Gen and 1 is model year 1958 . There were 5 3rd Gen sold in the last 5 years.

What's it Worth?

There are 16 comps for this 1958 Pontiac Star Chief indicating a price range from $17,600 - $79,198 .

Sell Your Vehicle

We'll help you price it right, then you can list it yourself.

Insure with Hagerty

info
Clicking on links for insurance will take you to an unaffiliated third-party-controlled site that is subject to that site owner's privacy policy and terms of use. CLASSIC.COM Inc. does not provide insurance and makes no representations on any coverage or options that are available by such third party.
Your location may include GeoLite2 Data created by MaxMind, available from https://www.maxmind.com.
Get a quote

Vehicle History

A timeline of events that we've detected for this vehicle.

Aug 12, 2025
Not Sold by Hemmings
30,807 mi TMU · South Windsor, Connecticut, USA
Aug 11, 2025
Not Sold at Hemmings
30,807 mi TMU · South Windsor, Connecticut, USA
Apr 16, 2025
Not Sold by Hemmings
30,807 mi TMU · South Windsor, Connecticut, USA

Comps

Comparable recent listings. See related attributes next to the score.

1958 Pontiac Star Chief

Original & Highly Original
6865 mi 2k mi TMU
Manual transmission Automatic
LHD steering LHD
Not Sold
$20,000
info
Highest Bid
Jul 24, 2023
94% Relevance
Relevance Score Criteria

Model
Year
Make
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
Model Trim
Powertrain
Engine
Transmission Type
Drive Type
Mileage
  • TMU
Body
Vehicle Type
Body Style
Doors
Driver Side
Ext. Color Group
Int. Color Group
Other Details
Originality
Location
Recency

1958 Pontiac Star Chief

Original & Highly Original
6865 mi TMU
Manual transmission Automatic
LHD steering LHD
Sold
$27,500
Jan 29, 2023
93% Relevance
Relevance Score Criteria

Model
Year
Make
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
Model Trim
Powertrain
Engine
Transmission Type
Drive Type
Mileage
  • TMU
Body
Vehicle Type
Body Style
Doors
Driver Side
Ext. Color Group
Int. Color Group
Other Details
Originality
Location
Recency

1958 Pontiac Star Chief Catalina

Original & Highly Original
6865 mi 4k mi TMU
Manual transmission Automatic
LHD steering LHD
Sold
$36,500
Jun 4, 2021
90% Relevance
Relevance Score Criteria

Model
Year
Make
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
Model Trim
Powertrain
Engine
Transmission Type
Drive Type
Mileage
  • TMU
Body
Vehicle Type
Body Style
Doors
Driver Side
Ext. Color Group
Int. Color Group
Other Details
Originality
Location
Recency

Specs

Details about this vehicle - curated by our market specialists.

Year
1958
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
Base Model
Model Trim
-
Engine
370ci V8 (6.1L)
Transmission
Automatic
Drive Type
Rear Wheel Drive (RWD)
Originality
Original & Highly Original
Mileage
30,807 mi TMU
VIN
P858H25415
Vehicle Type
Automobile
Body Style
Coupe
Doors
2 Doors
Driver Side
Left Hand Drive
Ext. Color Group
White
Int. Color Group
Red/Burgundy

Taxonomy

Markets related to the Pontiac Star Chief - 3rd Gen.

Pontiac Star Chief
directions_car 1st Gen
commute 2nd Gen
directions_car Standard Variants
directions_car Bonneville
directions_car 3rd Gen
directions_car 4th Gen
directions_car 5th Gen
directions_car 6th Gen