should i get the manual or automatic 2025 bmw m2?

Question

Accepted Answer

Great question! For the 2025 BMW M2, both transmissions are readily available right now—I found 22 automatics and 24 manuals currently listed on Classic.com.

**The quick takeaway:** If you want the purest, most engaging driving experience, go **manual**. If you want quicker acceleration and daily-driving convenience, go **automatic**.

Here's what the data shows:

**Pricing:**
- **Automatic:** $46,995 – $79,995 (avg. ~$66,400)
- **Manual:** $62,000 – $79,995 (avg. ~$69,500)

Manuals command a slight premium—about $3,000 more on average. The cheapest M2s are automatics, but at the top end, pricing is similar.

**The driving experience:**
The M2's 6-speed manual is a *really* good gearbox—short throws, crisp engagement, and perfectly matched to the S58 engine's character. It's the choice for purists who want that connected, old-school sports car feel.

The 8-speed automatic is objectively faster (0-60 in about 3.9s vs. 4.1s for the manual) and handles traffic/parking lot crawls with zero effort. It's also better for track days if you're chasing lap times.

**My take:** The M2 is an enthusiast's car at heart, and the manual suits its personality. That said, the automatic is excellent and won't leave you wanting. If this is a daily driver in heavy traffic, the auto makes sense. If it's a weekend toy or you just love rowing gears, the manual is worth the extra coin—and will likely hold its value better long-term.

Want me to show you some specific listings in either transmission? Or help you compare options in your area?

Lot TF04019: 2025 BMW M2

Classic cars

Cars for sale

Resources

Lot TF04019: 2025 BMW M2

Become a CLASSIC Insider