Lot TF04019: 2025 BMW M2

Great question! For the 2025 BMW M2, both transmissions are readily available right now—I found 22 automatics and 24 manuals currently listed on Classic.com.

The quick takeaway: If you want the purest, most engaging driving experience, go manual. If you want quicker acceleration and daily-driving convenience, go automatic.

Here’s what the data shows:

Pricing:

• Automatic: $46,995 – $79,995 (avg. ~$66,400)
• Manual: $62,000 – $79,995 (avg. ~$69,500)

Manuals command a slight premium—about $3,000 more on average. The cheapest M2s are automatics, but at the top end, pricing is similar.

The driving experience: The M2’s 6-speed manual is a really good gearbox—short throws, crisp engagement, and perfectly matched to the S58 engine’s character. It’s the choice for purists who want that connected, old-school sports car feel.

The 8-speed automatic is objectively faster (0-60 in about 3.9s vs. 4.1s for the manual) and handles traffic/parking lot crawls with zero effort. It’s also better for track days if you’re chasing lap times.

My take: The M2 is an enthusiast’s car at heart, and the manual suits its personality. That said, the automatic is excellent and won’t leave you wanting. If this is a daily driver in heavy traffic, the auto makes sense. If it’s a weekend toy or you just love rowing gears, the manual is worth the extra coin—and will likely hold its value better long-term.

Want me to show you some specific listings in either transmission? Or help you compare options in your area?