home chevron_right
For Sale
$40,995
Bay 22
verified
verified Verified Seller
Wyomissing, Pennsylvania, USA Wyomissing, Pennsylvania, USA
Bay 22
CALL 484-310-9205
OR
Wyomissing, Pennsylvania, USA
78,870 mi
Manual
LHD
Original & Highly Original
  • OVERVIEW
  • DESCRIPTION
  • MEDIA
  • SPECS
  • COMPS (30)
  • TAXONOMY
  • outlined_flag Report this Listing

About this 1991 BMW M5

VIN: WBSHD9311MBK06267

Bay 22 is an enthusiast owned European car dealership in Wyomissing, PA specializing in buying, selling and consigning Porsche, BMW, Audi and VW cars. Trade-ins welcome. Financing and transportation help available.

WBSHD9311MBK06267
78,871

1 of 4 globally Individual color E34 M5. 1991 BMW M5 in Brocade Red Metallic, said to be the only E34 M5 painted by BMW in this color. Black leather interior. This M5 was imported new on October 3, 1991 with all original importing documents included with the sale. The original window sticker is also included.

Ordered new and delivered to Montana in 1991, the car also spent time in California before coming to New Jersey and then eventually Texas. This E34 M5 was traded in from a larger collection towards an E92 M3. The owner purchased the car in April, 2018.

Brand new Michelin Pilot Sport 4S tires were installed, 245/45/17 square setup on a set of nicely refinished OEM Throwing Star wheels. The car has also received new suspension control arms, bushings, springs, and shocks new headlamps and fog lamps, and new headliner in the past 100 miles. Aftermarket, the car is running a Conforti chip and Eisenmann exhaust with an upgraded factory head unit. Otherwise, it's stock mechanically. Just the windows have been tinted.

The gauge cluster is sensitive to cold temps and the RPMs do not read until the interior temps are warm. The door panel coverings suffer from typical E34 delamination, though not bad, it is worth noting.

Comes with a binder full of receipts, original sales documents and window sticker. Also comes with a few spare parts headlights and fog lights.

Have a question? Ask Rusty
info
These answers are AI generated and may sometimes display incorrect information. They do not represent Classic.com's values or opinions. By using this chatbot you agree to our Terms and Conditions.

Rusty Logo beta

Get instant answers with AI powered search of listing information.

Powered by CLASSIC.com

Market Summary

The BMW M5 Sedan - E34 (1989 to 1995) market. See Similar Markets

CMB $29,189
The CLASSIC.COM Market Benchmark (CMB) represents a benchmark value for vehicles in this market based on data accumulated by CLASSIC.COM. Actual market value for a specific vehicle will depend on various elements, including the condition of the vehicle.
Loading...
Introduced for the 1989 model year, the E34 M5 Sedan was the first body style to debut for the E34 BMW M5. These performance-focused sedans ... Learn more.
There are 7 BMW M5 - E34 for sale across all model years (1989 to 1995) and variants, 5 are Sedan and 4 are model year 1991 . There were 105 Sedan sold in the last 5 years.

What's it Worth?

There are 30 comps for this 1991 BMW M5 indicating a price range from $28,600 - $33,202 .

Sell Your Vehicle

We'll help you price it right, then you can list it yourself.

Insure with Hagerty

info
Clicking on links for insurance will take you to an unaffiliated third-party-controlled site that is subject to that site owner's privacy policy and terms of use. CLASSIC.COM Inc. does not provide insurance and makes no representations on any coverage or options that are available by such third party.
Your location may include GeoLite2 Data created by MaxMind, available from https://www.maxmind.com.
Get a quote

Comps

Comparable recent listings. See related attributes next to the score.

1991 BMW M5

Original & Highly Original
6865 mi 80k mi
Manual transmission Manual
LHD steering LHD
Sold
$32,750
Oct 7, 2025
98% Relevance
Relevance Score Criteria

Model
Year
Make
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
Model Trim
Powertrain
Engine
Transmission Type
Drive Type
Mileage
  • 71K - 142K
Body
Vehicle Type
Body Style
Doors
Driver Side
Ext. Color Group
Int. Color Group
Other Details
Originality
Location
Recency

1991 BMW M5

Original & Highly Original
6865 mi 100k mi
Manual transmission Manual
LHD steering LHD
Sold
$33,500
Nov 26, 2025
96% Relevance
Relevance Score Criteria

Model
Year
Make
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
Model Trim
Powertrain
Engine
Transmission Type
Drive Type
Mileage
  • 71K - 142K
Body
Vehicle Type
Body Style
Doors
Driver Side
Ext. Color Group
Int. Color Group
Other Details
Originality
Location
Recency

1991 BMW M5

Original & Highly Original
6865 mi 82k mi
Manual transmission Manual
LHD steering LHD
Sold
$28,600
Oct 1, 2025
96% Relevance
Relevance Score Criteria

Model
Year
Make
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
Model Trim
Powertrain
Engine
Transmission Type
Drive Type
Mileage
  • 71K - 142K
Body
Vehicle Type
Body Style
Doors
Driver Side
Ext. Color Group
Int. Color Group
Other Details
Originality
Location
Recency

Specs

Details about this vehicle - curated by our market specialists.

Year
1991
Make
Model Family
Model Generation
Model Variant
M5
Model Trim
Standard
Engine
3.6L I6 (S38)
Transmission
Manual
Drive Type
Rear Wheel Drive (RWD)
Originality
Original & Highly Original
Mileage
78,870 mi
VIN
WBSHD9311MBK06267
Vehicle Type
Automobile
Body Style
Sedan
Doors
4 Doors
Driver Side
Left Hand Drive
Ext. Color Group
Burgundy
Int. Color Group
Black

Taxonomy

Markets related to the BMW M5 Sedan - E34.

BMW 5 Series - E34
directions_car Alpina B10
directions_car 535i
BMW 535i - E34
CMB $12,450
directions_car 520i
BMW 520i - E34
CMB $11,784
directions_car 525iX
BMW 525iX - E34
CMB $10,720
commute M5
directions_car Sedan
BMW M5 Sedan - E34
CMB $29,189
directions_car Touring
directions_car 525i
BMW 525i - E34
CMB $10,885
directions_car 530i
BMW 530i - E34
CMB $18,760
directions_car 525tds
BMW 525tds - E34
CMB $13,932
directions_car 540i
BMW 540i - E34
CMB $17,156
directions_car M540i
BMW M540i - E34
CMB $36,875
Loading seller information...
Vehicle information is provided by the seller or other third parties; CLASSIC.COM is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Price may exclude certain taxes, fees, and/or charges. See seller for details.